The 9 Best Baby Pacifiers Reviewed


Have you been trying to find out which pacifier is best for your child? For those who aren’t sure which baby pacifiers should be on your list, take a look at ours. Maybe you didn’t know that the best pacifiers for newborns actually prevent babies from having SIDS by helping them avoid sleeping too deeply.

The real question is which one makes the best pacifier. The truth of the matter is: your baby will have to make the final decision. For now, you can check out our list here of the best baby pacifiers on the market.


1. The Unscented JollyPop Pacifier

One of the best pacifiers for baby mouths is the JollyPop Pacifier due to the various sizes you can choose from — starting at preemie. You also have the option of purchasing a Razbuddy stuffed toy to help hold the pacifier. This popular Wabbanub brand also offers stuffed animals holding baby pacifiers, but they cannot be removed, unlike this JollyPop Pacifier.

The pacifier has a ring for the mom, the baby, or the stuffed animal to hold onto it with ease. The silicone pacifier was designed with a rounded nipple and a pronounced tip, making it easier for most babies to latch onto. But what makes it the best pacifier on the market is the option to purchase them in different scents in case your baby refuses all other pacifiers.


2. The Phillips Avent Soothie Pacifier

Phillips Avent Soothie Pacifiers are commonly distributed in the hospital after you’ve had your baby. The shape is rounded with very little definition from top to bottom. The nipple goes straight up with a few curves which many babies prefer.

Since it’s so similar to a real nipple, many people respect the popular brand thanks to their quality products. No harsh or suspicious materials were used to produce silicone pacifier. Plus, you can toss this into the dishwasher or simply use sanitizer to get it clean.


3. The Cutie Pat All-in-One Pacifier by Ryan & Rose

Another one of the best pacifiers for newborns and it’s too cute to ignore. The aesthetic favors a baby doll pacifier and it functions by having a teething ring on one side and a soother on the other. This is perfect for if your baby wants to chew on the ring for comfort as well.

It’s made of medical-grade silicone and doesn’t have any toxic elements. The nipple is similar to breastfeeding and the rounded nipple with the soft curves creates a natural palette development. The nipple also retracts so you can pop it in and out similar to a fidget toy.


4. The Ecopacifier by Ecopiggy

You can purchase the Ecopiggy one-piece pacifier in a rounded or orthodontic shape thought the rounded is more breastfeed-friendly. We recommend trying this pacifier if you’re looking for an all-natural soother for your baby. This one of the best baby pacifiers since it’s made of pure rubber from an Hevea Brasiliense rubber tree.

Rubber is a great material for a one-piece pacifier since it’s free of chemicals, colorants, and remains all-natural. Like other soothers on the market, this one is free of BPA, phthalate, plastic, PVC, and parabens. The rubber feels good against gums and resists their sharp teeth once they come in.


5. The Feeding Balance Cylindrical Pacifier by Evenflo

The simple design and purpose of this soother make it one of the best pacifiers for newborns on the market. Its rounded stage promotes an organic tongue position while mimicking the breast. It included an easy-grip handle, making it good for both mom and baby.

This one-piece pacifier is free of BPA, PVC, polycarbonates, and phthalates. The simple design makes it easy to clean. It also comes with a steam sanitizing bag you can pop in the microwave and reseal for a quick and easy cleanup.


6. The Closer to Nature Soother Pacifier by Tommee Tippee

What makes this the best infant pacifier is how closely it resembles a nursing nipple. The rounded shape has natural curves without any sharp angles. It’s the perfect shape for moms who want to transition from breast to baby pacifier with ease.

It’s designed from very soft silicone which makes it easy for latching while feeling like natural skin. The company also says that the shape is organically orthodontic. Since the material curves away from your baby’s mouth, it welcomes ventilation holes which also reduces rashes or skin irritations.


7. Nuk’s Newborn 100% Silicone Orthodontic Pacifier

One of the biggest advantages of this baby pacifier is that it comes in four different sizes. The average brand offers to or three sizes but Nuk offers a wider variety for every stage of your baby’s growth. You can find a size for your 0-2 month-old, your 0-6-month-old, 6-18 month-old, and your 18-36 month-old.

Outside of the variety of sizes, Nuk offers a truly orthodontic shape designed to lower jaw and palate pressure. It’s made of silicone and has an asymmetrical shape to help with oral development. The scoop-shaped nipple helps with full tongue movement which invites gentle exercise and helps proper teeth alignment.


8. The Natural Rubber Baby Pacifier for BIBS

This Denmark brand has a baby pacifier with a nipple that doesn’t lay close to the skin which prevents drool rash. Instead, your baby can self-soothe rather than using your breast for comfort. The shape of their all-natural pacifier closely imitates a mother’s breast.

It’s a simple design that has a timeless style and a variety of earth tones to also easily coordinate with outfits. It’s free of PVC, BPA, and phthalates. There’s also a ring to help the baby hold the pacifier while soothing themselves. Remember that the more comfortable your baby, the easier it is for them to stay happy!


9. The Flex Baby Pacifier by Nanobébé

The Flex Baby Pacifier by Nanobébé has worked perfectly for well-breastfed babies and has a nipple similar to an actual one. This silicone pacifier featured gentle curves that make for easy sucking. The shields also come in different colors such as Teal, White, Gray, and Pink!


Find the Best Baby Pacifiers Today

Now that you have this handy list, finding the best baby pacifiers should be a breeze! You can choose from a variety of soothers without having to break the bank. And remember that the final test will always come down to your baby’s response to the pacifier.


Happy shopping!